Somebody not liking your game as much as you do through your fanboy glasses does not means they hate it...
they just do not use your fanboy-glasses and see the problems which also exist.
BotW is a good and solid game. It makes fun, got a beautiful world etc. etc.
However!!! It has design flaws which are unavoidable and probably annoyed most of the people playing the game.
The weapon durability system is horseshit... if weapons would "just" break and you could repair them if you bring them to a smith, probably ppl would be more ok with it. At last, it is a neat addition but executed horrible in a way that annoys and is not an addition to the gameplay.
Cooking is fun, but not in BotW. Yes it is neat for the first few times you do it but then you notice a big bummer: You lack a ton of quality of life (from now just refered to as QOL) features. Starting at the simplest: you cannot easily repeat your last cooking or make a bunch with the same. Just crafting eg. a potion feels cumbersome due to you being in need of having the right stuff in your inventory (which is fine) but you cannot see if you even got the right category of items. Due to the interface design, it simply does not feels right when you continue playing and need to cook to get health items, potions etc. it feels like you waste your time as this could be more simple. A simple book for example that opens up and allows to recraft anything you like. Picking ingredients would still be simple, but should be limited to what actually can be used in the current recipe
Motion Control shrines are just awful! It does not feels right to be in need of precise movement when you always can 100% freely move and rotate your object. They feel completly unnatural and anybody thinking they are "nice addition" is right, just that the execution is so wrong. Examples? There are shrines where you have to move a hammer with motion controls. So far so good right? But the hammer just has to swing from the left to the right, hitting a large ball. This however is deadly hard simply because the moment you start moving your joycon, the game moves the hammer. When you then rotate the hammer, the ball will fall off the ledge simply because your hammer is rotated slightly. This feels awful and youre happy when youre done with it. No challenge just pure anger about a broken mechanic.
The defensive mechanics like Shield Parry or jump-avoid are also completly horrible. The timing spot is way to short to get it off reliably, the enemies do not announce their attacks good enough to visually feel it, ... There is simply so much wrong with this mechanic... not to mention that the moment there is more then one enemy, you are simply fucked because all of theese things will not work anymore. So even if you by magic sit through hours to learn to parry correctly, it is no usable skill simply because the enemy behind you will just straigth hit you without a chance to parry or actually see that he is there.
could continue days with this! And it is awful that you fanboys do not want to notice this.
Do theese things hinder me from playing the game? Fuck no. But they exist! Everybody touching the game will experience them, everybody will get annoyed by them (you too) and everybody normal will not enjoy theese things as much as they could.
Theese are the reasons, why BotW should not be even considered as a Game of the Year ...
but they also do not make the game a bad one ... it is just not a perfect game.